Everything posted by govt2310
-
Is FAR 15.503(b) Postaward Notice of Award still required after Corrective Action?
Vern wrote: Technically, this is not a "new" award. Yes, we have simply take corrective action, which involved reevaluation and a new source selection decision/memo. It happens to be that the "new" awardee is the original awardee. Note, the original protest involved allegations that the agency did not take certain information into account when evaluating past performance. So in the corrective action, that "new" PP info was taken into account. The original protest was filed at GAO only, and the agency took corrective action.
-
Is FAR 15.503(b) Postaward Notice of Award still required after Corrective Action?
Say an agency sent out FAR 15.503(B ) Postaward Notice of Award letters to unsuccessful offerors. Written debriefings were provided to all of them. After a protest was filed, the agency decided to take Corrective Action. The Corrective Action involved reevaluating the proposals. While it was reevaluating the proposals, the agency did not "terminate" the original contract award to the original awardee, but rather, "suspended" their contract and did not allow them to work. Now the agency has completed its new reevaluation. The same awardee from the initial evaluation is also the awardee after Corrective Action. Must the agency send "new" FAR 15.503(B ) Postaward Notice of Award letters to ALL the unsuccesful offerors? Can the agency send the Notice of Award letters to ONLY the unsuccessful offeror that protested last time? Technically, this is not a "new" award in the sense that, there is no new contract being awarded, but rather, the contract with the original awardee, which was "suspended," will now be "unsuspended" so the contractor can start performing the work.
-
Air Force interesting approach to best value. Wise to use this?
The Performance-Price Tradeoff (PPT) method raises practical issues. When agencies try to use PPT for "FAR Part 15" solicitations, PPT does not allow for compliance with FAR 15.306(c ) (it requires evaluation "against all evaluation criteria"). In PPT, usually the solicitation will say that Price is evaluated first, then only those proposals found to have F&R price move on to be evaluated for Technical, then only those proposals found Technically Acceptable move on to be evaluated for Past Performance. If an agency intends to hold discussions, and they want to do a Competitive Range, it looks like the agency could just do the Competitive Range "cut-off" by including in discussions only those offerors with technically acceptable proposals. In other words, an agency does not have to evaluate on "all" evaluation criteria, as the agency does not even get to evaluating Past Performance until after the Competitive Range has been made. But I can see how a disgruntled offeror might see this as the agency failing to comply with FAR 15.306©. As far as I know, GAO has not addressed this specific question.
-
How to evaluate for Balanced Pricing
Does anyone have any guidance on how a CO is supposed to evaluate for "Balanced Pricing" in a Price Analysis? Some colleagues have proposed using the "Total Allocation of Price" or "Total Allocation of Cost" method for determining Balanced Pricing. I have never heard of this method before. Is anyone here familiar with it? Does anyone have any other methods for determining whether a price/individual CLINs are "balanced"?
- Can agency downgrade past performance rating if the offeror only submits its subcontractor's work?
- Can agency downgrade past performance rating if the offeror only submits its subcontractor's work?
- Can agency downgrade past performance rating if the offeror only submits its subcontractor's work?
-
Can agency downgrade past performance rating if the offeror only submits its subcontractor's work?
EXCELLENT/HIGH CONFIDENCE: Based on the Offeror's recent and relevant performance record, hte Gov't has a high expectation that hte Offeror will successfully perform the required effort. GOOD/SIGNIFICANT CONFIDENCE: Based on the Offeror's recent and relevant performance record, the Gov't has a reasonable expectation that hte Offeror will successfully perofrm the required effort. FAIR/SOME CONFIDENCE: Based on the Offeror's recent and relevant performance record, the Gov't has a low expectation that hte Offeror will successfully perform the required effort. NO CONFIDENCE: Based on the Offeror's recent and relevant performance record, the Gov't has no expectation that hte Offeror will be able to successfully perform the required effort. NEUTRAL/UNKNOWN CONFIDENCE: No recent and relevant performance record is available or the Offeror's performance record is so sparse that no meaningful confidence assessment rating can be reasonably assigned.
-
Can agency downgrade past performance rating if the offeror only submits its subcontractor's work?
A solicitation requires offerors to submit Past Performance. It further states that the agency will consider the Past Performance of the offerors' proposed subcontractors if it is submitted. One of the offerors submits a proposal containing the past performance of its subcontractor. The past performance is considered Very Relevant, and the PP surveys are all "Excellent." The evaluators rate the offeror's Past Performance as "Neutral." Why? They say that, because the glowing Past Performance was done by the subcontractor, not the prime, and there is always a general risk that the prime will not be able to manage the subcontractor in such a way as to achieve the same level of high performance (Excellent), the evaluators "downgrade" the overall Past Performance from "Excellent" to "Neutral." Does this sound reasonable?
- What if Offeror's Proposal Info and Past Performance Reference differ on relevancy?
- What if Offeror's Proposal Info and Past Performance Reference differ on relevancy?
- What if Offeror's Proposal Info and Past Performance Reference differ on relevancy?
-
What if Offeror's Proposal Info and Past Performance Reference differ on relevancy?
Offeror Acme submits a timely proposal to a solicitation. Acme's proposal contains a Past Performance (PP) Volume with narrative describing its performance on Three Past Contracts. On Past Contract #1, Acme described it as a $30 million total value contract for 5 years. Acme sends Past Performance Questionnaires (PPQs) to its PP references. Those PP references fill out the PPQs and provide them to the agency. When the agency reviews the PPQs, it finds the reference for Past Contract #1 states that the Past Contract #1 was for $24 million for 3 years. Assume that Past Contract #1 was a commercial contract for a private company, not a government agency. QUESTION: What should the agency do? Should the agency believe the Offeror or the PP reference on what the total value and period of performance was for the contract?
-
Can agency just award to highest-rated, highest-priced proposal without explaining the tradeoff? (PPT Question)
Jacques, The GAO decision says, "Additionally, to the extent the SSA made a tradeoff decision, we find the source selection decision here to be reasonable." My concern is, why didn't the GAO attorney simply write, "The SSA made a tradeoff decision, and we find it reasonable"? Why say, "to the extend the SSA made a tradeoff decision"? That seems to imply that there was no tradeoff, and that was ok, because the solicitation said that award would go to the offeror with "Substantial Confidence" and reasonable price.
- Can agency just award to highest-rated, highest-priced proposal without explaining the tradeoff? (PPT Question)
-
Can agency just award to highest-rated, highest-priced proposal without explaining the tradeoff? (PPT Question)
QUESTION: Can an agency just make award to the highest-rated, highest-priced proposal without explaining the "tradeoff"? I saw a recent GAO decision that makes me wonder about this. In Green Earthworks Construction, Inc., B-410724 et al., Feb. 2, 2015, the Air Force issued a solicitation for abatement services for hazardous materials. Here is the link to the GAO decision: http://www.gao.gov/assets/670/668348.pdf The RFP stated that there were only TWO EVALUATION FACTORS: PAST PERFORMANCE and PRICE. Although it did not use the phrase "Performance Price Tradeoff (PPT)," it appears that this was some variation on PPT. The proposals would be ranked from low to high for price. Price analysis would only be conducted on the "lowest-priced proposals." Next, the agency would evaluate for Past Performance. If the lowest-priced proposal also received a "Substantial Confidence" PP rating, then award would be made to that offeror, Otherwise, the PP assessment would continue, beginning with the next lowest-priced proposal, until an offeror with a substantial confidence rating was identified. If that didn't work out, then the SSA was to determine whether additional higher-priced groups of proposals should be considered and to then conduct a "best-value tradeoff." Green Earthworks challenged the source selection decision. GAO denied that challenge, finding that the awardee, All Phase, merited award under the stated terms of the solicitation: All Phase was the only proposal among the lowest-priced group that received a substantial confidence rating: Offeror A, Somewhat Relevant/Satisfactory PP, $2,450,362.00 Green Earthworks (Protester), Somewhat Relevant/Limited confidence PP, $2,487,585.86 All Phase (Awardee), Very Relevant/Substantial Confidence PP, $2,917,515.93 It appears that GAO is saying, no tradeoff was necessary because the RFP said that award would go to the proposal with Substantial Confidence. GAO wrote, "Additionally, to the extent the SSA made a tradeoff decision, we find the source selection decision here to be reasonable." Then GAO goes on to cite FAR 15.308 ("Source selection decisions must be documented, and include the rationale and any business judgments and tradeoffs made or relied upon by the SSA"). However, if you search for the RFP No. FA4620-14-R-B002, it actually shows the RFP was not done under FAR 15, but rather, it was a FAR Part 13 Simplified Acquisition. Link to the solicitation on FBO: https://www.fbo.gov/?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=cdce9fdbdd905d584d9fee2ea7911ba1&tab=core&_cview=1
-
Thoughts on FSSIs
A few weeks ago, FITARA became law. FITARA, found in Sections 831-837 of the NDAA FY15, appears to require that federal agencies must use GSA's FSSI BPAs/IDIQs or they have to justify why they are not using them. Any thoughts on this? See Section 836 of the NDAA FY15 online at this link: http://www.wifcon.com/dodauth15/dod15_836.htm and see the entire NDAA FY15 in PDF on GPO's site at this link: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-113hr3979enr/pdf/BILLS-113hr3979enr.pdf
-
Thoughts on FSSIs
What is the difference between ordering off the GSA FSS (Federal Supply Schedule)/GSA Schedule, and placing an order off one of the GSA FSSI BPAs? Why would an agency choose one over the other? Depending on the dollar value, it looks to me from my reading of FAR 8.405-3© that ordering of any BPA does not get rid of competition requirements. What is so great about FSSI?
-
FAR 13.003 what is an "appropriate combination" of FAR Parts 13 and 14?
Thanks everyone!
-
FAR 13.106-1: can the basis of award be "price only"?
Thanks everyone!
-
Can FAR 12.6 be used on its own, or must it always be combined with FAR Part 13 or 15?
Thanks! Interesting. I have seen GAO decisions that describe the facts as if the agency used FAR 12.6 "on its own." But they also describe the solicitation involved as an "RFQ." So by inference, the agency must have done the solicitation under FAR Part 13.
-
Can FAR 12.6 be used on its own, or must it always be combined with FAR Part 13 or 15?
Can FAR 12.6 be used on its own, or must it always be combined with FAR Part 13 or 15? If so, how?
-
FAR 13.106-1: can the basis of award be "price only"?
Where in CICA, 41 USC 3301 et al. (for civilian agencies), does it say that CICA does not apply to SAP? Where does it say that FAR Subpart 6.4 does not apply to FAR Part 13 Simplified Acquisitions (competitive)?
-
FAR 13.106-1: can the basis of award be "price only"?
FAR 13.106-1(a)(2) states, in part: When soliciting quotations or offers, the contracting officer shall notify potential quoters or offerors of the basis on which award will be made (price alone or price and other factors, e.g., past performance and quality) . . . MY QUESTION: Is it truly possible for an agency to put in a solicitation using FAR Part 13, Simplified Acquisition Procedures, that the basis of award will be "price alone"? I thought CICA required the use of sealed bidding if price and price-related factors were the only basis of award.
-
FAR 13.003 what is an "appropriate combination" of FAR Parts 13 and 14?
FAR 13.003(g) states: (g) Authorized individuals shall make purchases in the simplified manner that is most suitable, efficient, and economical based on the circumstances of each acquisition. For acquisitions not expected to exceed— (1) The simplified acquisition threshold for other than commercial items, use any appropriate combination of the procedures in Parts 13, 14, 15, 35, or 36, including the use of Standard Form 1442, Solicitation, Offer, and Award (Construction, Alteration, or Repair), for construction contracts (see 36.701(a)); or (2) $6.5 million ($12 million for acquisitions as described in 13.500(e)), for commercial items, use any appropriate combination of the procedures in Parts 12, 13, 14, and 15 (see paragraph (d) of this section). What does "appropriate combination" mean? I am having a tough time imagining what a solicitation would look like if it combined FAR Part 13, SImplified Acquisition Procedures, and FAR Part 14, Sealed Bidding. Does anyone have illustrative examples?


