Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The Wifcon Forums and Blogs - 27 Years Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Vern Edwards

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Vern Edwards

  1. Is it safe to conclude that you don't like the policy? BTW, it's not socialism in any meaningful sense. That's claptrap. It's clientelism (client politics). In any case, the government has dictated facets of employers' hiring procedure for decades. What's new about that? https://www.eeoc.gov/prohibited-employment-policiespractices#:~:text=The laws enforced by EEOC prohibit an employer or other,%2C and pregnancy)%2C or national See Francis Fukuyama on clientelism in Political Order and Political Decay.
  2. Do you know how many GAO protest decisions there have been about the GSA FSS "logical follow-on" exception? Five, since 1998. Do you know how many have been sustained? None. Do you how many protests against the exception have been filed with the Court of Federal Claims? One. Do you know the result? The court ruled for the government. The standard for the GSA FSS logical follow-on exception is not much of a problem. You don't need a lawyer.
  3. Here is what I think has happened: 1. You know that FAR Subpart 25.1 and 25.2, which address the Buy American Act, include no exemption for small business set-asides. 2. You also know that FAR 25.401(a)(1) exempts small business set-asides from the trade agreement policies in FAR Subpart 25.4. 3. Then you saw that FAR 25.1102(c) prescribes FAR 52.225-11, Buy American-Construction Materials under Trade Agreements (my emphasis), for use in contraction contracts, but prescribes no exemption for small business set-asides, and the FAR provides no explanation or information that solves what appears to be a paradox. Do I have it right? Well, the clause prescription does strike me as peculiar, so I have discussed the matter with others and sought an understanding. But I have found nothing anywhere that resolves the matter. I know very little about FAR Part 25. I have always found FAR Part 25 and its predecessors in the old Defense Acquisition Regulation (DAR) and Armed Services Procurement Regulation (ASPR) to be extremely complicated and difficult to understand. Those rules seriously challenge my attention span. And when conducting an acquisition we have to get on with things. We can't afford to get bogged down. I think ji20874's advice boils down to this: Just comply with the clause prescription and move on. In this case, I think that's reasonable advice. No one could justly criticize you for doing that. In the very last line of your opening post you said: Frankly, when we start thinking, talking about, and looking for the "spirit" of a law, we have stepped off the main road and are on the road to perdition. In this case I think you should get back on the main road, unless your name is Montesquieu. "Steal Captain Black's car. That's what I always do." Thanks for the puzzle. You were thinking, and I learned something.
  4. See also 25.100(b). I found no such statement in FAR Subpart 25.2.
  5. See FAR 25.101(b): "The Buy American statute applies to small business set-asides."
  6. Oh, for Pete's sake: "in the interest of economy and efficiency" Translation: in order to save the time and money that would have to be spent bringing a new contractor up to speed. See Harmonia Holdings Group LLC, GAO B-417465, 2019 CPD ¶ 257, July 18, 2019: Now, how hard was that to answer?
  7. See DOD DPC memo USA000182-21-DPC. https://www.acq.osd.mil/dpap/policy/policyvault/USA000182-21-DPC.pdf Emphasis added. The DAU curriculum will be tied to it.
  8. @govt2310If you want to make two (or more) awards from one solicitation, one award for one "market segment" and one for another "market segment," and want to use different approaches for selecting the contractor(s) for each segment, begin by establishing one contract line item for the first market segment and one for the second. Then, in Section M of the RFP (supposing that you are using the Uniform Contract Format), describe the evaluation approach (tradeoff or LPTA) and factors for the first CLIN and do the same for the second CLIN. Essentially, you conduct two source selections under a single solicitation. It is clearly permissible. It is easy. And I just told you how to do it. ji20874 told you how to explain it in the solicitation. You joined Wifcon in 2009. You are not a newbie.
  9. @acq20wlWhat do you mean by "fees"? What "fees"? You said your contract is firm-fixed-price. "Fee" is not ordinarily a term we use with respect to FFP contracts. What "fees" have increased?
  10. I have changed my mind. I'm not going to comment. I watched the video that Carl posted, and I think it would be pointless to do so. The standard appears to be the product of a big committee.
  11. I am happy for Bob to publish articles that I have written, but I will not discuss them here other than to say that I have written what I have written and it's been peer reviewed. When I have anything to add or alter I do it in the same publication, also subject to peer review.
  12. I knew that they had developed a standard, but I had not read it. Now that I have, I'm horrified. From page 5: And, on the same page: Italics in original. 🧐 😞 The quality of writing (and thinking) is the same throughout. I would be embarrassed to show it to anyone as a consensus standard for the work that contract managers do. I will send comments, but I do not expect to see any improvement, given the short deadline for submittal. I suspect that they are eager to move on and are just following protocol.
  13. @govt2310 You have posted twice in this thread. and Unless I have missed a post, the only question you have asked is in the first sentence of the first post, in bold above. Is that still the question? "Has anybody ever seen..."? Do you have another question?
  14. The risk you run with that approach is that the information provided to offerors as the bases for firm-fixed line item pricing—statements of work or some other descriptions—do not accurately or completely reflect what will really be demanded of the contractor during performance. That would be a recipe for dissatisfaction and litigation.
  15. @here_2_help The first sentence in the Assad memo says: The definition of B&P in FAR 31.205-18: So Assad's first sentence makes sense to me. But we have been talking about proposal preparation and negotiation costs that are required by contract. Those are ordinarily allocated as direct costs of the contract which required the proposal and negotiation support. However, FAR 31.202 says: Much earlier in this thread you agreed with me that charging proposal and negotiation costs required by contract does not turn them into B&P costs. (I should have challenged you on that business about "in practice nobody really ever makes that distinction," because it is demonstrably false. But I let it go, because I know that people in our business can be careless about terminology.) But then you said: The phrase "as being B&P costs" in that comment threw me for two reasons. First, because it seems to erase the important distinction between (1) proposal and negotiation costs that ARE required by contract and (2) B&P costs, which are such costs that are NOT required by contract. Second, it threw me because Assad's memo says no such thing! Not even close! Yesterday, you said: My emphasis. Again, your words seem to erase the distinction between proposal and negotiation costs required by contract and B&P costs by saying that costs required by contract may or may not be "part of B&P expenses"! I think we agree, but you have not been precise in the way you have expressed yourself in some of your posts in this thread. You know me. Imprecision can hurt businesses. That's why they have to resort to lawyers. Words and sentences matter in the contracting world. That's why I try to "mimic" lawyers, because the best of them know that, and they have taught me. Unschooled and inexperienced people are easily confused and misled by careless language about complicated, even esoteric, business matters. We must not mislead unschooled and inexperienced readers who come to this site "to learn," as they like to say. I shall now say what I think you mean: Proposal and negotiation costs that are required by a contract are to be allocated as direct costs of that contract, but may in some cases—for sake of "practicality,"—be allocated as indirect costs in the same way as B&P costs. However, the two categories of cost remain distinct, even when both are allocated as indirect costs. Thus, requirements that expressly apply to B&P costs, such as 10 USC 3763, DFARS 242.771-1, and many others, do not apply to proposal and negotiation costs that are required by contract, not even when they are allocated as indirect costs. Does that work for you? If it does, then we can close the book on this topic. And while we're at it, "selling costs," which are mentioned in the title of this thread, are not the same as B&P costs. I have the highest respect for you as a professional and a practitioner. Website chat sites are not the best place to discuss legally complex matters. Best, Vern
  16. Thanks, H2H, but I cannot find anything in the Assad memo that supports the following assertion: My emphasis. That memo consists of exactly 20 sentences. I have read each and every one. And, unless I am losing it, or have been blinded by prejudice, not one of those 20 sentences supports that assertion. (Could we be talking about different memos?) Maybe I just don't understand what you mean by "such support expenses." It's either that or I disagree with what you seem to be saying. But I'll let it go. I know what I think, and that's enough for me. Costs incurred for the preparation of proposals that are required by contract are not, and by official definition cannot be, considered or treated as bid and proposal (B&P) costs. There are requirements that apply to B&P that do not apply to the other costs, no matter how they are allocated. Whether they are charged as direct or indirect depends on circumstances and the contractor's established accounting practices. See FAR 31.202. If they are charged as indirect, they are not B&P costs just for that reason. Best, Vern P.S. I remember disputes such as this among the senior contract specialists when I was a newbie. They were often just matters of confusion over communications transmitted and received.
  17. @joel hoffmanWhy are you inserting yourself at this point? This morning, H2H said: My emphasis. I've asked him for clarification. He's a big boy. He doesn't need your help. Why don't you just wait for him to respond to my query? Stand by, for Pete's sake.
  18. The question is whether the cost of proposals and negotiations required by contract that are allocated indirectly are to be treated "as being B&P costs." The reason why that is important is that there are distinct management issues and concerns that pertain specifically to each kind of proposal costs. See, for instance, DFARS 242.771. See also 10 USC § 3763 (formerly § 2372a). While contractually required costs may be allocated indirectly under appropriate circumstances, such costs do not become B&P when so allocated and should not be treated "as being B&P."
  19. Emphasis added. @here_2_helpI consider you an expert in these matters and so am hesitant to disagree with you. But I'm not certain about what you are meant by the quoted sentence. When you say "contract negotiation costs" do you mean the cost of proposals and negotiations required by contract? If so, then I must disagree with you. I wonder if I have misinterpreted you. 48 CFR 31.205-18 defines "bid and proposal costs" as follows: 48 CFR 9904.420-30(a)(2) (CAS 420) defines "bid and proposal cost" as follows: Those regulations appear in the current Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) and have the force and effect of law. I am holding Shay Assad's November 10, 2011 memorandum, the one you cited last Friday at 9:00 a.m. and this morning. It is entitled, "Memorandum." The word "directive" does not appear therein, neither does the word "shall." The word that I see is "guidance." It contains six paragraphs. Nowhere therein do I see any sentence that says DOD will accept the costs of proposals and negotiations required by a contract "as being B&P costs." My point is that while the costs of preparing and negotiating a proposal that is required by contract may be charged as indirect costs under certain circumstances, as provided by FAR 31.202, charging them as such does not make them "bid and proposal costs" as defined by FAR and CAS. That is my only point. It's a narrow point, but I think it is an important one. COs should understand the different purposes and roles of the two kinds of proposal costs. Do you take issue with my point? Do you think that Assad said that proposal and negotiation costs required by contract can be treated "as being B&P costs" as defined by FAR and CAS? If so, would you point out the paragraph and sentence in which Assad said that? If I missed it and he did say it, do you think it was sound guidance. I apologize if I'm just being a blockhead in the way I read and am reacting to your last post.
  20. There is no reason to think that. See FAR 31.202, Direct costs: This really is simple. There are two kinds of proposal costs. There are (1) the costs of proposals for new work and (2) the costs of proposals required by contract. Both types of proposal costs are allowable, but (1) is allocable only as indirect costs while (2) may be allocated as either direct or indirect under appropriate circumstances, as described in FAR 31.202. Until 1996 there were ceilings on the costs of proposals for new work that the government would compensate, which are called B&P costs. B&P is defined such that contractually required proposal costs were not included. That's because (a) contractually required proposal costs are direct costs and (b) no one wanted the ceilings to apply to costs that had to be incurred to comply with contracts. Thus, it was important to recognize the distinction between the two kinds of costs. When the ceilings were eliminated, the FAR councils did not change the definition of B&P. Assad's memo indicated that if the costs of proposals required by contract were to be allocated as indirects, they could both be included in a B&P pool. For many contractors, combining the two types of proposal costs was administratively easier. But Assad's memo was careless, and confusing to those unfamiliar with the cost principles. True B&P costs, as still defined by FAR 31.205-18, must be allocated indirectly. That is usually done by maintaining a B&P cost pool and including it in the G&A cost pool. Proposal costs required by contract are direct costs, but for the sake of convenience they may be allocated either directly or indirectly according to a contractor's consistent cost accounting practice. Assad said that could be done by including them in the B&P cost pool, which is usually part of the G&A cost pool, or by including them in their own pool and then including that pool in the G&A pool. But including the costs of proposals required by contract in the B&P pool does not make them B&P costs as defined in FAR. Also, I have been unable to confirm that Assad's 2011 memo is still active guidance.
  21. In a recent decision the CBCA cited FAR as "48 CFR ...." For example, from a very recent decision: "Appellant has requested dismissal of this appeal pursuant to Rule 12(b)(2) (48 CFR 6101.12(b)(2) (2020))." That date refers to the annual edition. That seems to be the preferred style. The version would depend on the date of the contract action. The ASBCA might cite it as "FAR...." For example: "A claim is a 'written demand or written assertion by one of the contracting parties seeking, as a matter of right, the payment of money in a sum certain ... arising under or relating to the contract.' FAR 2.101." Again, the version would depend on the date of the contract action. The COFC seems to cite it as "FAR...." For example: "FAR § 52.212-1(g), however, also allows the government to “waive informalities and minor irregularities in offers received.” Waiver under this regulation is discretionary." Date of the contract action. The GAO seems to cite "48 CFR." For example, "The Federal Acquisition Regulations require that the government's notice of termination include the 'effective date of termination.' 48 C.F.R. § 49.102(a)(2)." Again, the version that would apply would depend on the date of the contract action.
  22. The regulation says "any termination." Are you terminating each order separately, so that there are three distinct terminations, or are you terminating the contract and all on-going orders in a single action? Don't answer. Just think about it.
  23. @Jamaal ValentineFrom the ecfr website, https://www.ecfr.gov/reader-aids/using-ecfr/getting-started Note the phrase "legal edition," which refers to the currently and legally effective text of the moment. Legal edition and official edition are not the same thing. An "official" version of the CFR is simply one that is published by an office with the authority to do so. There is more than one official version of the CFR. What the legal version is at any particular moment must be determined through legal research. Acquisition.gov declares itself to be an "official" website, so a FAR or agency supplement text at acquisition.gov is "official", but it may not be the legally effective version. By definition, the text in a FAR class deviation is different from the currently legally effective text of the FAR (or DFARS). That's why it's called a deviation. FAR permits deviations. Deviations do not change the currently legally effective text. The text of a clause deviation must not be presented as a "version" of the CFR text, even though it may be applied in practice. FAR 1.404, Class deviations, says: "When an agency knows that it will require a class deviation on a permanent basis, it should propose a FAR revision, if appropriate." There has been some dispute about the legality of class deviations that have not undergone the publication and comment rule in 41 USC 1707, but its current status is muddled. See Tesoro Hawaii Corp. v. U.S., 405 F.3d 1339 (CAFC, 2005). See also "Agency Policy Memos: The Statutory Publication and Public Comment Rules Apply," The Nash & Cibinic Report (February 2011); "Postscript: Agency Policy Memos," The Nash & Cibinic Report (November 2013); and "Postscript II: Agency Policy Memos," The Nash & Cibinic Report (February 2014). I don't doubt that DOD class deviation could be presented at acquisition.gov, but for I don't think they should be presented as "a version of the DFARS" for the reasons I set out above. DFARS deviations are not part of the DFARS, they are deviations from the DFARS. There is no question that Fara Fasat is right to say that something could be done to make it easier to determine the existence of class deviations applicable to FAR contract clauses. But once that has been said there is no point in going on about it. The FAR councils make policy, but have never seemed to care about facilitating day-to-day legal research. A competent person can find the class deviations in short order. It's a pain, but laws and regulations are generally a pain. Those who think the DAR Council should do something to make life easier should write to the DAR Council.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.