Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The Wifcon Forums and Blogs - 27 Years Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Vern Edwards

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Vern Edwards

  1. As to your last comment, read the motto at the bottom of this post. I believe that. What I wrote was what I thought was good advice. I still think it's good advice. I was on your side, and you didn't annoy me. I just felt it was urgent, given the deadline, that you seek legal advice instead of chat room advice. But touché.
  2. But the clause says: If the WTO GPA and FTAs apply, doesn't that contradict a broad interpretation of 25.401(a)(1)?
  3. I think you are misinterpreting FAR 25.401(a)(1). I think that because I have read the Trade Agreements Act. It mentions small business only once, at 19 USC § 2511. That section reads, in pertinent part, as follows: I think that all 25.401(a)(1) means is that the Trade Agreements Act does not preclude the use of small business set-asides. I do not think it means that agencies cannot waive the Buy American Act with respect to countries with trade agreements when conducting a small business set-aside, which is all that FAR Subpart 25.4 and 52.225-11 do. If it meant that, it would mean that small businesses and the government would have to abide by the Buy American Act under a set-aside even when domestic construction materials are too expensive or unavailable. Think of what the implications would be for bonding, which is not an issue under supply contracts. But what do I know?
  4. Ha! So Lionel has got you thinking. I told you that two days ago.
  5. To what does your "NO" refer? Are you saying they are not clueless? Well, au contraire! If they haven't read the clause they are clueless. Paragraph (e) of that clause has been word-for-word the same for more than 30 years, except that 30 years ago the reference to "(d)" was to "(c)". If you are working on service contracts covered by the SCLS and do not understand the clause and how overhead and G&A work you are clueless and in over your head when talking about the price adjustment. The clause creates no significant practical issues or issues of accounting.
  6. I don't recall this having been mentioned in any of the above, but noncompliance with the clause prescription at FAR 25.1102(c) for whatever reason would constitute a FAR deviation. See the definition of "deviation" at FAR 1.401(b): Of course, someone among you is almost certainly going to argue that using the clause in accordance with its prescription would be a deviation as defined at FAR 1.401(a), since you argue that its use is inconsistent with FAR 25.401(a)(1). Either way, someone among you could argue that whichever you decide to do you must proceed in accordance with FAR 1.403. See also FAR 1.405. Forgive me if any of this was mentioned in any earlier post. Seeking a deviation on the basis of the arguments presented in this thread might be a way to resolve the controversy. We work in a utopia of rules.
  7. You won't find answers bickering here. I gave you the best answer you're going to get at this website several posts ago. If you want a better answer write to the FAR councils. I think the civilian agency council handles Part 25.
  8. @WifWaf That's nonsense. You are delving into a matter that is clearly over your head. Price adjustment based on Service Contract Act wage determinations was a well-settled matter more than 40 years ago. The OP is just clueless, as are you.
  9. I would ask for a meeting, right away, disclose my problems, and seek to negotiate a better way for both parties to manage the return to prior conditions rather than to arbitrarily declare March 31 as THE date. When did they notify you? I would definitely seek the advice of counsel, because I doubt that the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals or the Court of Federal Claims would let them get away with it, unless they notified you of the March 31 return some time ago. Covid was a historically earthshaking event. It was beyond anyone's fault or negligence, except perhaps the president's and the Center for Disease Control's. After two years of massive disruption, it may well be arbitrary and capricious of the government to unilaterally set a date for the return to normalcy. You are not without recourse. Having said that, you will eventually have to solve the problem within a reasonable time and to your customer's satisfaction. Call a lawyer. And get off Wifcon. Your company needs professional advice. March 31 is right around the corner.
  10. If I was the staff reviewer of the solicitation/contract file and you had inserted any clause in the solicitation/contract other than the one prescribed by FAR, I would reject your file and send it back unapproved. And I wouldn't engage in any Socratic Q&A or listen to your bs argument. And the next time one of your files came to me I would go over it with a scanning electron microscope. 👎 😁 🧐 😎
  11. The rates will go down if the base is labor dollars.
  12. In short, an increase in direct labor costs caused by an increase in wages and fringe benefits does not cause an increase in the indirect costs that are allocated as overhead and G&A. That's why the price adjustment clause does not provide for an increase in overhead and G&A. Nothing is provided for profit because the government simply does not want to pay more profit because of an increase in wages and fringes.
  13. @KeithB18Yes. I like this quote from the page 9: And this from page 149: I don't think that's entirely true, because Congress and presidents like to add programs without adding people and funds to implement them. But when you trace the history of some procurement rules you'll see that the politicians launch a program, complain about the failures of implementation, then add more rules to enforce the first rule, and so on and so forth. Think of the small business limitations on subcontracting. Things have gotten out of hand. We have reached a worrisome state of governmental incompetence, in part because our politicians (I refuse to call them leaders) try to do too much through procurement rules and then don't provide the human resources and training needed to pull it off, assuming that it could be pulled off. It makes me question their sincerity. I think a lot of what they enact is for show, mostly with the next election in mind. Procurement plays an important role in government operations, and these political initiatives are choking the process. It's going to catch up with us. It's catching up with us now.
  14. Some quotes, from which I urge you all to draw your own conclusions. From FAR 1.102-4(e): "Contracting officers should take the lead in encouraging business process innovations and ensuring that business decisions are sound." FAR 1.602-1(b): "No contract shall be entered into unless the contracting officer ensures that all requirements of law, executive orders, regulations, and all other applicable procedures, including clearances and approvals, have been met." From FAR 1.602-2: "Contracting officers are responsible for ensuring performance of all necessary actions for effective contracting , ensuring compliance with the terms of the contract , and safeguarding the interests of the United States in its contractual relationships." From FAR 1.603-2: "In selecting contracting officers, the appointing official shall consider the complexity and dollar value of the acquisitions to be assigned and the candidate’s experience, training, education, business acumen, judgment, character, and reputation." From FAR 15.405(a): "Taking into consideration the advisory recommendations, reports of contributing specialists, and the current status of the contractor’s purchasing system, the contracting officer is responsible for exercising the requisite judgment needed to reach a negotiated settlement with the offeror and is solely responsible for the final price agreement." From Penner Installation Corp. V. U.S., 116 Ct. Cl. 550 (1950): "Some contracting officers regard themselves as representatives of the defendant, charged with the duty of protecting its interests and of exacting of the contractor everything that may be in the interest of the Government, even though no reasonable basis therefor can be found in the contract documents; but the Supreme Court has said that in settling disputes this is not his function; his function, on the other hand, is to act impartially, weighing with an even hand the rights of the parties on the one hand and on the other." From "Postscript II: The Role of the Contracting Officer," by Vernon J. Edwards, The Nash & Cibinic Report (2010) "While on paper COs are powerful figures, in reality there are many socio-organizational constraints on their autonomy and on the role that they play in the acquisition process. Not the least of those factors is their lack of expertise. With few exceptions, the image of the autonomously decisive CO is a myth. Yet we believe that a CO who is respected for his or her knowledge, experience, and skill can exercise considerable, perhaps even decisive, influence over the decisionmaking process. That is, a CO can play a meaningful role, not by relying on formal authority, but on the power of reasoning, explanation, and persuasion. The ABA Section of Public Contract Law's upcoming conference would do well to ask how the Government can develop a corps of competent COs capable of exercising their formal authority. That is really the question of the day." From "Postscript II: The Role of the Contracting Officer—Addendum," by Professor Ralph C. Nash, Jr., The Nash & Cibinic Report (2010): "A CO must (1) be able to assist requisitioners in preparing work statements that allow effective procurement, (2) be as aware of procurement policies as agency staff personnel, (3) be able to separate legal advice from policy advice masquerading as legal advice, and (4) be fully able to deal with accounting and pricing issues. These are a lot of skills but traditionally our best COs have had them all. See our previous discussions in The Contracting Officer: Defining the Role, 10 N&CR ¶ 58, and Postscript: The Role of the Contracting Officer, 13 N&CR ¶ 15. But even with all of these skills, a person will not be able to fulfill the FAR role if he or she does not have the necessary personality trait of feistiness. A good CO has to be able to deal effectively with all of the other Government people that Vern describes but also has to strongly represent the Government's interests in dealing with contractors. This means negotiating to get the right price from the contractor most likely to perform well. It requires a strong person with considerable self esteem to effectively negotiate with contractors and agency personnel to arrive at the best business decision for the agency. It's a great job for such a person but a clerical job for one without the necessary skills and personality." From The Quality and Professionalism of the Acquisition Workforce, Report, House Armed Services Committee, May 8, 1990: "The contracting officer is the fulcrum of the acquisition process." From "Motivation Reconsidered: The Concept of Competence," by Robert H. White, Psychological Review, Vol. 66, 1959: "As used here, competence will refer to an organism's capacity to interact effectively with its environment. In organisms capable of but little learning, this capacity might be considered an innate attribute, but in the mammals and especially man, with their highly plastic nervous systems, fitness to interact with the environment is slowly attained through prolonged feats of learning."
  15. @Lionel: I agree with your analysis of the TAA and I agree that 52.225-11 clause implements the BAA. I don't think think FAR 25.401(a)(1) has anything to do with it. But most importantly, I agree with ji20874 that the right thing to do is comply with FAR clause prescriptions.
  16. I'm not sure what "when hired" means. Does it mean hired as an experienced contract specialist or when hired out of college?
  17. @Lionel Hutz The relevant text of the Trade Agreements Act is in 19 USC § 2511(f): Next FAR 25.401(a)(1) says: What does that mean? It must mean that under a set-aside the CO need not do the things required and need not refrain from doing the things prohibited. I cannot think of what else it could mean. So, what does the subpart require and prohibit? What are the shalls and shall nots that do not apply to set-asides. There are nine sections within Subpart 25.4—25.400 through 25.408. (1) 25.400 states the scope of the part. It neither requires nor prohibits anything. (2) 25.401 lists exceptions and services excluded from the WTO/GPA. (3) 25.402(a)(2) says that the CO must determine the origin of services by country in which the firm providing the services is established. (4A) 25.403(a) explains a couple of things but does not say that anyone shall or shall not do anything. (4B) 25.403(b) explains the application of dollar thresholds. (4C) 25.403(c) says to acquire only U.S.-made or designated country end products or services unless no offers are received or the offers are insufficient. (5) 25.404 says that for certain acquisitions construction materials and services must be treated as end products. (6) 25.405 says certain construction materials and services must be treated as end products. (7) 25.406 says that certain agencies must evaluate Israeli offers without regard to Buy American restrictions/ (8) 25.407 says that the Trade Representative has waived Buy America statute for civil aircraft. (9) 25.408(a) specifies certain procedures the CO must follow when the WPO/GPA applies: (1) and (2)synopsize, (3) not include technical requirements designed to preclude acquisition of eligible products, (4) state the offers must be in English and in U.S. dollars, (5) notify unsuccessful offerors as required by FAR. It refers readers to FAR Subpart 25.5 for evaluation procedures. So that's it. That's all that does not apply to small business set-asides. How about we move on from FAR 25.401(a)(1).
  18. @MileHighAcqYour "solicitor" (are you British?) has developed a faulty opinion. The proper clause to use in acquisitions valued at more than the $7,032,000 trade agreements threshold is FAR 52.225-11, as prescribed by FAR 25.1102(c). I will explain. Everyone- There is no conflict between FAR 25.401(a)(1) and FAR 52.225-11, which implements the Buy American Act. The Buy American Act, which applies to supply and construction procurements, requires the use of domestic construction materials, but provides for exceptions. See 41 USC 8303(b). FAR 52.225-11 is the product of the 1999 "FAR Part 25 Rewrite," FAC 97-15, 64 FR 72416-01, Dec. 27, 1999. It implements the Buy American Act by requiring the use of domestic construction materials, but grants a blanket exception for construction materials from countries with trade agreements. The key language in the clause is this: Before the FAR Part 25 Rewrite, the construction clause was FAR 52.225-15, Buy American Act-Construction Materials Under Trade Agreements Act and North American Free Trade Agreement (JUN 1997). It imposed the Buy American Act on construction acquisitions. It also established an arduous procedure whereby an offeror or contractor could apply to the contracting officer for an exception allowing the use of materials from nations with U.S. trade agreements. Here is the procedure for contractors: A separate procedure for offerors is prescribed in the solicitation provision at FAR 52.225-10(b). Apparently, individual requests for exceptions in large construction procurements had become common. So rather than process numerous individual requests for Buy American exceptions, the FAR Part 25 Rewrite did away with all that by creating the FAR 52.225-11(b)(1) blanket exception that we now know and love. In short, what FAR 52.225-11(b)(1) does is allow companies to use construction materials obtained from countries with U.S. trade agreements ("designated" countries) in procurements valued at more than $7,032,000 without having to apply for an exception. FAR 52.225-11(c) prescribes a procedure for requesting an exception for materials from other foreign countries. So what about FAR 25.401(a)(1)? The Buy American Act and small business set-asides are considered discriminatory trade practices. In 1978-79, members of the World Trade Organization (WTO) negotiated the "Tokyo Round" Agreement on Government Procurement (AGP). The signatories to the WTO/AGP agreed not to apply discriminatory practices to foreign trade partners. The Trade Agreements Act approved the president's agreement to the WTO/AGP. The Trade Agreement Act is a set of exceptions to the Buy American Act, and is implemented by FAR Subpart 25.4 The U.S. appendix to the WTO/AGP provided that the agreement would not prohibit the use of small and minority business set-asides. That is the basis for FAR 25.401(a)(1). But FAR 25.401(a)(1) does not prevent the government from allowing exceptions to the Buy American Act and allowing purchases of materials from foreign trade partners when domestic products are unavailable or too costly, so there are exceptions. Thus, FAR 52.225-11(b)(1). The bottom line is: You cannot understand FAR 25.401(a)(1) without some background. FAR 52.225-11 must be used as prescribed by FAR 25.1102(c). (A fun fact: When FAR was published in 1984, 52.225-11 was named "Certain Communist Areas.") I traveled a tortuous, hours-long path of research to dig up and polish the above nugget. I had to condense a lot of information in order to fit it into a reasonably brief post. I don't like writing long stuff in this online forum, but I don't think I made any big mistakes. Hopefully, this post is clear enough to settle the debate. During the course of my research I downloaded well over one thousand pages of historical documents. I learned lot about the history of the Trade Agreements Act. Thank goodness for the internet. I don't sleep much, and it has worried me. But, sometimes, it has its rewards. I get in lots of reading. Please remember me fondly after Alzheimers sets in.
  19. @Lionel HutzHere's 19 U.S.C. 2511(f): I don't think that says what you indicated it says.
  20. There is no single correct answer. It depends on (1) the agency's mission and (2) the complexity and volume of the work. When I started out as a GS-05 trainee in August 1974 at the USAF Space and Missile Systems Organization (SAMSO), COs were GS-14s or GS-13s and journeymen contract specialists were GS-12s. The contract specialists had several years of experience as such. The average contract specialist was much, much more expert than the average CO today. COs did not conduct acquisitions. Contract specialists conducted acquisitions. COs supervised the contract specialists, gave direction, made decisions and recommendations, reviewed files, and signed contracts, modifications, and other documents that required CO signatures. CO appointments were hard to come by. After CO review, but prior to issuance of an RFP and prior to contract award in excess of a certain dollar value, a contract specialists contract files had to be reviewed by the Judge Advocate's office and then by "The Committee". The Committee was chaired by a GS-15 and was staffed by GS-14s. First there was an administrative review by a GS-12, then there was a substantive review by a GS-14. The GS-14s reviewed every file, page-by-page, and made written findings and directed or recommended changes. COs could challenge directions and recommendations to the Committee chair. Unresolved issues were decided by a colonel (O-6) or by his deputy, a GS-16 (now SES). Very large contracts that had to be approved by a command four-star or the Secretary of the Air Force had to be further reviewed by the Committee at the Air Force Systems Command headquarters. In the late '70s and early 80s I was a GS-13 contracting officer at SAMSO in the Space Defense program office, which was headed by a brigadier general. I supervised the work of two contract specialists. My boss, the director of contracts for Space Defense, was a lieutenant colonel. He managed two contracting officers. We had adequate, but not ample, clerical support. It is my opinion that the idea of contracting officers being, in effect, working-level contract specialists who sign their own work, has diminished the status of contracting officers, degraded the contracting career field, and resulted in generally poor quality work.
  21. It would clearly be in violation of the clause prescriptions. But at this point I think we're all just trying to understand. For instance, what is the authority for the exception for set-asides, and what is the rationale?
  22. How do you know that? There have been goofs in the FAR. You referenced training by the Trade Representative. Did you attend a class? Is the class available on line?
  23. See clause paragraph (b)(1): "(b) Construction materials. (1) This clause implements 41 U.S.C.chapter 83, Buy American, by providing a preference for domestic construction material." FAR Part 25 and its provisions and clauses are a mess.
  24. Don't worry folks. It'll might five years or longer for the FAR councils to develop a final rule based on the E.O. They'll almost certainly wait for OPM to issue its final rule. We are living in a utopia of rules. We are the most rule-crazy people on the planet. Way to go attracting all those innovative companies to government work.
  25. Is it safe to conclude that you don't like the policy? BTW, it's not socialism in any meaningful sense. That's claptrap. It's clientelism (client politics). In any case, the government has dictated facets of employers' hiring procedure for decades. What's new about that? https://www.eeoc.gov/prohibited-employment-policiespractices#:~:text=The laws enforced by EEOC prohibit an employer or other,%2C and pregnancy)%2C or national See Francis Fukuyama on clientelism in Political Order and Political Decay.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.