November 3Nov 3 comment_99902 In it's proposed rule for RFO Part 16, the overhaulers propose to raised the approval level for use of FFP LOE contracts over a certain dollar threshold from the chief of the contracting office to the head of the agency!!!!The proposed rule would revise FAR part 16 to adhere to the preference for fixed-price contracts with performance-based considerations, and adds justification and approval requirements for other than fixed-price contracts and firm-fixed-price, level-of-effort term contracts. New section 16.104 describes the justification and approval requirements.An FFP LOE contract can include performance-based (i.e., quality) requirements!16.104 Executive Order 14402 justification for covered contracts and orders.(a) Definition. As used in this section, covered contract or order means a contract or order that is—(1) Other than fixed-price;(2) Firm-fixed-price, level-of-effort term; or(3) A hybrid contract that includes one or more elements described in paragraphs (1) and (2).(b) Policy. This section implements Executive Order 14402, Promoting Efficiency, Accountability, and Performance in Federal Contracting, April 30, 2026. The head of the agency must approve a written justification described in paragraph (d) of this section prior to using a covered contract or order.(c) Application. (1) Thresholds. Unless an exception in paragraph (e) of this section applies, a justification is required for covered contracts and orders valued at or above—(i) $100 million, for DoD;(ii) $35 million, for NASA;(iii) $25 million, for Department of Homeland Security; or(iv) $10 million, for all other Federal agencies.(2) Hybrid contracts or orders. A hybrid contract or order is a covered contract or order when the value of the other than fixed-price or firm-fixed-price, level-of-effort term portion meets or exceeds the thresholds.(3) Single-award indefinite-delivery contracts. A single-award indefinite-delivery contract (IDC) is a covered contract if the estimated total value of the known and forecasted covered orders meets or exceeds the thresholds. Use the contract ceiling price if the contract only allows for covered orders.(4) Blanket purchase agreements. The head of the agency decides whether the justification requirement applies when the blanket purchase agreement (BPA) is awarded, or when each order under the BPA is placed.(5) Duration of a justification. An approved justification is valid for the duration of the contract or order.(d) Procedures. (1) Submit to the head of the agency the required justification for approval that includes—(i) The information in section 16.103; and(ii) Any determination and findings required for the contract type (see 12.104(b)(1), 16.401-2, 16.501-3).(2) The head of the agency may only delegate the justification approval to the chief acquisition officer of the agency or another non-career official in the Senior Executive Service within the agency.(e) Exceptions. The justification requirement does not apply to—(1) Multiple-award contracts. However, the justification requirement does apply to task orders, delivery orders, and BPAs under those contracts;(2) Contracts in support of a response to an emergency, major disaster, or contingency operation;(3) Research and development contracts or orders (see part 35); or(4) Pre-production development for a major system acquisition (see part 34).The E.O. does not mention FFP LOE contracts.16.206-1 Description.A firm-fixed-price, level-of-effort term contract requires—(a) The contractor to provide a specified level of effort, over a stated period of time, on work towards a deliverable that can be described in general terms; and(b) The Government to pay the contractor a fixed dollar amount for the effort.48 CFR 16.206-216.206-2 Application.A firm-fixed-price, level-of-effort term contract is suitable for investigation or study in a specific research and development area. The deliverable of the contract is usually a report showing the results achieved through application of the required level of effort. However, payment is based on the effort expended rather than on the results achieved.48 CFR 16.206-3 • 48 CFR 16.206-4 • 48 CFR 16.207-1 • 48 CFR 16.207-2 • 48 CFR 16.207-316.206-3 Limitations.This contract type may be used only when—(a) The work required cannot otherwise be clearly defined;(b) The required level of effort is identified and agreed upon in advance;(c) There is reasonable assurance that the intended deliverable cannot be achieved by expending less than the stipulated effort; and(d) The agency head approves a justification if required by 16.104.Boy! That's the way to speed things up and encourage innovation.I don't think the Overhaulers understand FFP LOE contracts or their usefulness in the acquisition of support services, for which they are now widely being used. Report
November 3Nov 3 comment_99903 Why?Agreeing that the approval level is a departure from Executive Order 14275 which states "Accordingly, the FAR should contain only provisions required by statute or essential to sound procurement, and any FAR provisions that do not advance these objectives should be removed." I am guessing that someone some place decided that FFP-LOE is akin to cost reimbursement and or T&M/LH contracts. As such the Overhaulers are acknowledging the inability of the acquisition workforce to administer such contracts for all kinds of reasons discussed alot in Forum. My guess most especially the reasons of less than adequate staffing and less than adequate knowledge. The statutorily dictated requirements applicable to the Chief Acquisiton Officer purusuant 41 USC 1702 continue to be washed away.....REF: 41 USC 1702(b)(3)(G)&(H) -"(G)developing and maintaining an acquisition career management program in the executive agency to ensure that there is an adequate professional workforce; and(H)as part of the strategic planning and performance evaluation process required under section 306 of title 5 and sections 1105(a)(28), 1115, 1116, and 9703 (added by section 5(a) of Public Law 103–62 (107 Stat. 289)) of title 31—(i)assessing the requirements established for agency personnel regarding knowledge and skill in acquisition resources management and the adequacy of those requirements for facilitating the achievement of the performance goals established for acquisition management;(ii)developing strategies and specific plans for hiring, training, and professional development to rectify a deficiency in meeting those requirements; and(iii)reporting to the head of the executive agency on the progress made in improving acquisition management capability." Report
November 4Nov 4 Author comment_99906 "I am guessing that someone some place decided that FFP-LOE is akin to cost reimbursement and or T&M/LH contracts.Anyone who thinks that is professionally ignorant. Report
November 4Nov 4 comment_99908 It goes against the latest policy emphasis of delivering clearly defined results for a fixed price. Report
November 4Nov 4 Author comment_99910 5 hours ago, formerfed said:It goes against the latest policy emphasis of delivering clearly defined results for a fixed price.How does it do that?A "clearly defined result" could be the conduct of a quality study or the provision of quality support services up to a specified level of effort within specified term of service for a firm-fixed price.The FFP-LOE contract is the least understood of all contract types. Report
November 4Nov 4 comment_99912 13 hours ago, Vern Edwards said:Anyone who thinks that is professionally ignorant.Dare I say they are reaping what they sow to a degree regarding the acquisition workforce. The workarounds to avoid such approval levels are killing sound acquisition decisions by good CO's! Report
November 4Nov 4 comment_99913 I think this is all from a lack of understanding. Perhaps someone saw this contract type improperly used in the past. Or they are thinking it’s like a grant. It’s easy to say better define your requirement. Report
November 4Nov 4 Author comment_99914 The first mention of FFP LOE in regulations was in the ASPR in 1971. Like so many things, it was a field invention that was adopted and regulated. It was never fully explained. Just a few sentences.What you have to do is think it through, which is not a widespread practice in our field.The RFO's explanation for its proposed rule is absurd. The idea that FFP LOE's can't have performance standards is ridiculous.They have needlessly restricted the use of one of the best contract types in this era of multi-million dollar support services contracts. There are some "professionals" who think T&M and L-H contracts are better!!! Report
November 9Nov 9 comment_99925 One thing in the text Vern posted: the multiple-award exception in 16.104(e)(1) doesn't buy much, because it pulls task orders back in. Most support services are bought now as orders against MACs, so a civilian FFP LOE order at $10 million needs a written justification signed by the head of the agency, the CAO, or a noncareer SES. Under the old FAR 16.207-3(d) the approval above the SAT sat with the chief of the contracting office. That is a big jump in altitude for an order that may be one of dozens on the same vehicle.My guess at what actually happens: nobody wants to send a support services order to a political appointee, so the same work gets written up as FFP completion with a vague deliverable, or carved up to stay under the line. Neither is better for the government. The FFP LOE at least says honestly what is being bought: a defined amount of qualified effort over a term, at a price the contractor has to live with. Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.