September 10Sep 10 comment_99678 Does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award other transaction agreements (OTAs) independent of any other authority to award OTAs?If yes, does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award an OTA that is NOT a "follow-on production contract or transaction" as defined in 10 USC 4022?10 USC 345810 USC 4022 Report
September 10Sep 10 comment_99679 Funny to see these questions as I was reading about thisDefenseScoopPentagon partners with venture studio to pilot shared sav...This unique agreement is designed to demonstrate a new framework where vendors are paid only for the costs they eliminate. Report
September 11Sep 11 comment_99688 On 9/10/2026 at 12:35 PM, Don Mansfield said:Does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award other transaction agreements (OTAs) independent of any other authority to award OTAs?If yes, does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award an OTA that is NOT a "follow-on production contract or transaction" as defined in 10 USC 4022?10 USC 345810 USC 4022I have read the statutes, and I have no idea.Congress and executive branch policy makers are turning contracting into a chaotic clown show. Spend time at SAM.gov reading contracting opportunities and you'll realize that the "system" has gone stark raving mad. Report
September 12Sep 12 comment_99693 On 9/10/2026 at 12:35 PM, Don Mansfield said:Does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award other transaction agreements (OTAs) independent of any other authority to award OTAs?If yes, does 10 USC 3458 authorize DoD to award an OTA that is NOT a "follow-on production contract or transaction" as defined in 10 USC 4022?10 USC 345810 USC 4022 1. YesYes if it is for a protype OT. Report
September 12Sep 12 comment_99695 I searched for a statutory or an official definition of prototype and didn’t find much. Here are a couple sources I found. The second is from the Strategic Institute.I wondered what could be included in the OTA award in the DefenseScope article I posted earlier. So it seems like what can be considered “prototype” is broader than I thought.What Constitutes a Prototype Project?The terms “prototype” and “prototype project” are not defined in statutes or regulations. However, in 2002, the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics stated:“With regard to section 845 authority, a prototype can generally be described as a physical or virtual model used to evaluate the technical or manufacturing feasibility or military utility of a particular technology or process, concept, end item, or system. The quantity developed should be limited to that needed to prove technical or manufacturing feasibility or evaluate military utility. In general, Research, Development, Test & Evaluation (RDT&E) appropriations will be appropriate for OT prototype projects.”Strategic Institute for Innovation in Government ContractingWhat Qualifies as a “Prototype” for an Other Transactions...What is a prototype? What seems to be a simple question with a simple answer is sometimes mysterious when trying to determine if a project falls under Other Transactions statutes. First, it is impo… Report
September 12Sep 12 Author comment_99696 31 minutes ago, formerfed said:I searched for a statutory or an official definition of prototype and didn’t find much. Here are a couple sources I found. The second is from the Strategic Institute.I wondered what could be included in the OTA award in the DefenseScope article I posted earlier. So it seems like what can be considered “prototype” is broader than I thought.Strategic Institute for Innovation in Government ContractingWhat Qualifies as a “Prototype” for an Other Transactions...What is a prototype? What seems to be a simple question with a simple answer is sometimes mysterious when trying to determine if a project falls under Other Transactions statutes. First, it is impo…10 USC 4022 defines "prototype project" as follows:____The term "prototype project" includes a project that addresses-(A) a proof of concept, model, or process, including a business process;(B) reverse engineering to address obsolescence;(C) a pilot or novel application of commercial technologies for defense purposes;(D) agile development activity;(E) the creation, design, development, or demonstration of operational utility; or(F) any combination of subparagraphs (A) through (E).Notice how it uses "includes" instead of "means", implying the definition is broader. Report
September 13Sep 13 comment_99699 On 9/12/2026 at 10:24 AM, formerfed said:I searched for a statutory or an official definition of prototype and didn’t find much.The word prototype appears in 164 places in the United States Code. I found no definitions.10 U.S.C. § 4022, Authority of the Department of Defense to carry out certain prototype projects, does not include a definition of prototype.There are eight definitions of prototype in the Code of Federal Regulations. Here are the cites:10 CFR 435.50216 CFR 1632.116 CFR 1632.616.CFR 1633.219 CFR 10.9119 C.F.R. Pt. 181, App.19 C.F.R. Pt. 182, App. AI have a texbook, Product Design and Development, 7th ed., by Ulrich et. al. (2020), which defines prototype as follows:"We define prototype as 'an approximation of the product along one or more dimensions of interest."'Chambers Technical Dictionary (1998) defines prototype as: "Generally, the first original type or model from which anything is developed."ChatGPT defined it as follows: "A prototype is an early or test version of a product, design, or idea made to see how it works before creating the final version."The DOD Prototyping Guidebook, ver. 3.1 (2022), says:The term “prototype” is defined in numerous ways in DoD, defense industry, commercial industry, and academic literature. All of the definitions have merit, and, not surprisingly, all of them are similar. For the purposes of this guidebook, please use the following definition: Prototype: a model (e.g., physical, digital, conceptual, and analytical) built to evaluate and inform its feasibility or usefulness. Report
September 29Sep 29 comment_99755 looks like BUSINESS ENABLED ACQUISITION AND TECHNOLOGY, INC., v. United States, Case 1:26-cv-01025-CNL, raised this issue in one of their COFC briefingsOn 9/13/2026 at 2:43 PM, Vern Edwards said:The word prototype appears in 164 places in the United States Code. I found no definitions.10 U.S.C. § 4022, Authority of the Department of Defense to carry out certain prototype projects, does not include a definition of prototype.There are eight definitions of prototype in the Code of Federal Regulations. Here are the cites:10 CFR 435.50216 CFR 1632.116 CFR 1632.616.CFR 1633.219 CFR 10.9119 C.F.R. Pt. 181, App.19 C.F.R. Pt. 182, App. AI have a texbook, Product Design and Development, 7th ed., by Ulrich et. al. (2020), which defines prototype as follows:"We define prototype as 'an approximation of the product along one or more dimensions of interest."'Chambers Technical Dictionary (1998) defines prototype as: "Generally, the first original type or model from which anything is developed."ChatGPT defined it as follows: "A prototype is an early or test version of a product, design, or idea made to see how it works before creating the final version."The DOD Prototyping Guidebook, ver. 3.1 (2022), says:Also, 10 USC 4022(a)(3)(e)(5) defines "prototype" for the purpose of the statute as (5) The term "prototype project" includes a project that addresses-(A) a proof of concept, model, or process, including a business process;(B) reverse engineering to address obsolescence;(C) a pilot or novel application of commercial technologies for defense purposes;(D) agile development activity;(E) the creation, design, development, or demonstration of operational utility; or(F) any combination of subparagraphs (A) through (E). Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.