May 19May 19 comment_98771 Consider the following situation:An agency intends to award multiple definitized (non-IDIQ) contracts for a class of services. The FAR part 15 procedures apply. The agency is seeking a range of approaches defined approaches. Let's call them A, B, C, and D. Some offerors can provide all approaches; some can only provide two or three. The agency is not looking to hit any defined quotas (e.g., one of each approach). It wants redundancy and expects each approach to be performed by two or more contractors.Stated evaluation factors include technical capability, quality, experience, and past performance.The agency informs offerors that it will determine the best-value proposals using a two-phase process.In Phase 1, it will perform tradeoffs between price and non-price factors and rank the proposals by overall strength. At this point the agency determines the Best-Value Range, which is composed of the prospective awardees.In Phase 2, it will perform a correlation analysis. If any of the approaches (A, B, C, or D) are under-represented, the agency may replace an offeror in the Best-Value Range with one another from outside of the Best-Value Range. In other words, the agency may decide that its need for sufficient coverage across all approaches outweighs the relative strength of a proposal. (Assume that the agency has a strong, mission-driven reason for performing the correlation analysis and replacing a comparably stronger offeror with a weaker one.)Questions: Is such a source selection methodology compliant with the FAR? If the agency received a protest before the solicitation closed, would this approach survive scrutiny? Why or why not? Report
May 19May 19 comment_98772 @FrankJon Two questions:What do you mean by "approach"? What is an "approach"? Is it a process, procedure, or method?What do you mean by "correlation analysis"? I know what it means in statistics, but I'm not sure what procedure you are talking about. What "correlation"?What is your definition of "best value range"? How is it different from competitive range? Report
May 19May 19 Author comment_98774 52 minutes ago, Vern Edwards said:@FrankJon Two questions:What do you mean by "approach"? What is an "approach"? Is it a process, procedure, or method?What do you mean by "correlation analysis"? I know what it means in statistics, but I'm not sure what procedure you are talking about. What "correlation"?What is your definition of "best value range"? How is it different from competitive range?Vern - What do you think of this source selection procedure? Specifically, utilizing a correlation analysis as a final step.I'm referring to a statistical correlation analysis. The work is financial in nature and lends itself to this. If you'd like, you can think of this as any source selection consideration that is outside of the ability of offerors to control. Recall that the agency intends to make multiple awards. I invented the term Best-Value Range to describe the group of prospective awardees once negotiations, final evaluation, and tradeoffs are completed. These are the offerors who will receive award unless the results of the correlation analysis dictate otherwise. Report
May 19May 19 comment_98776 FrankJon,Similar procedures to your suggestion have been utilized before. It’s somewhat related to cascading evaluations used to ensure small business receive representative share of awards.Several agencies, including VA, also employed that procedure to provide adequate competition coverage under multiple award IDIQ contracts. The solicitation hypothetically covers multiple functional areas and offerors are free to propose on one or more functional areas. The solicitation states an objective is ensuring there are at least three awards for each functional area. The agency goes through something similar to your Phase 2. If an insufficient number of awards result for any functional area, they reserve the right to bring one of more offerors outside the “Best Value Range.” They simply picked who is next in line in ranking. Report
May 19May 19 comment_98778 2 hours ago, FrankJon said:Vern -What do you think of this source selection procedure? Specifically, utilizing a correlation analysis as a final step.Well, I don't really understand the procedure. It seems needlessly complicated. Why not just say that you're going to make multiple awards based on the number of "apporaches" proposed and let it go at that. (I assume that the proposed "approaches" are fully specified offers and that they will be incorporated into the respective statements of work upon acceptance.) Just treat each award as a separate source selection decision.I don't understand the application of correlation analysis in this procurement. Correlation of what to what? Is it a price realism thing? If your team errs in its application or execution of the technique it might end badly.But, again, I don't really understand what you're planning to do, so don't pay attention to me. Report
May 19May 19 Author comment_98779 1 hour ago, formerfed said:The agency goes through something similar to your Phase 2. If an insufficient number of awards result for any functional area, they reserve the right to bring one of more offerors outside the “Best Value Range.” They simply picked who is next in line in ranking.It seems like the distinction would be that in my case, we wouldn't merely be bringing in a weak proposal for award, but swapping out an otherwise capable and deserving offeror for a weaker one because the weaker one happens to fill the remaining service gaps better than the stronger one. Report
May 19May 19 comment_98783 1 hour ago, FrankJon said:It seems like the distinction would be that in my case, we wouldn't merely be bringing in a weak proposal for award, but swapping out an otherwise capable and deserving offeror for a weaker one because the weaker one happens to fill the remaining service gaps better than the stronger one.Wouldn’t it make more sense to just bring on an additional award rather than replacing one? Report
May 19May 19 comment_98784 3 hours ago, formerfed said:Wouldn’t it make more sense to just bring on an additional award rather than replacing one?It makes more sense to me.The correlation analysis thing makes no sense to me. It comes across as somebody trying to be "innovative". Report
May 20May 20 Author comment_98788 15 hours ago, formerfed said:Wouldn’t it make more sense to just bring on an additional award rather than replacing one?11 hours ago, Vern Edwards said:It makes more sense to me.The correlation analysis thing makes no sense to me. It comes across as somebody trying to be "innovative".Gents - To be clear, I’m not proposing to do anything. An agency has utilized this approach and intends to continue to do so. The reasons for doing so are rational and, in any event, the requirement office isn’t keen on changing its approach. My question is whether this runs afoul of procurement rules or principles. Personally, it rubs me the wrong way to potentially disqualify an offeror over reasons outside of its control. But I struggle to articulate why it’s impermissible. The best I can muster is that it’s akin to unstated evaluation criteria. Even though the agency alerts offerors as to its intention to conduct a correlation analysis, offerors have no way to prepare for it or guard against removal from the Best Value Range. It’s a crap shoot. They have to propose good value and then hope that their proposal is sufficiently complementary to other proposals. Report
May 20May 20 comment_98789 1 hour ago, FrankJon said:My question is whether this runs afoul of procurement rules or principles.Possibly. But the answer depends on the procedural details. The process you described in your opening post strikes me as peculiar, but if fully explained in greater and accurate detail, and if clearly described in the RFP, it might make perfect sense and be okay.I say let them try it and see what happens. Maybe nothing. Just make sure they can't blame you for an unhappy outcome Report
May 20May 20 Author comment_98792 2 hours ago, Vern Edwards said:Possibly. But the answer depends on the procedural details. The process you described in your opening post strikes me as peculiar, but if fully explained in greater and accurate detail, and if clearly described in the RFP, it might make perfect sense and be okay.I say let them try it and see what happens. Maybe nothing. Just make sure they can't blame you for an unhappy outcomeThanks for your thoughts, Vern. Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.